NYC Bagels

Carol Sheppard 2 months ago

I ordered $142 worth of food. As sion as I placed the order I was told to cancel. I even got a text saying the order was cancelled. Then today I noticed I was billed on my Amex card. I called for a reimbursement and was told that they have nothing to do with this. $142 is alot of money to lose. Use them at your own discretion. I will continue posting until I am reimbursed my $142 and 24 cents

Shaqwanna Sutton 3 months ago

I love this bagel shop it reminds be of being home. Even though The bagels are a little smaller Then a bagel you would get from Long Island, New York. But the bagels and breakfast sandwiches are amazing. I haven’t tried anything else yet, but when I do, I would definitely let you guys know.

Mildred Banks 3 months ago

I was in the area and stopped to grab a bite but this was my first and last time. I ordered scrambled eggs, bacon, hash browns and a croissant. The only decent items on my plate were the eggs and croissant. The hash brown was store bought not fresh and the bacon if you can call it that was the thinnest bacon I have ever had. I ordered coffee and I just couldnt drink it. It tasted awful, like it was brewed hours ago, so i ordered a fountain drink, and that tasted terrible as well. This platter and coffee was $18, the fountain drink $3.45 so I spent a total of $21.45 on my ordered. I think they are overpriced and honestly they are ripping people off just because the establishment name "NYC Begals". I am from NY and let me tell you, they are given real NYC begals a bad name.

Mallory Cyr 6 months ago

Since moving to the Cary area, this has become our go-to spot for bagels. I usually order delivery, so I can’t speak much to the in-store experience, but the food itself consistently delivers. I’m pretty particular about bagels, and these absolutely hold up—great texture, a good chew, and generous toppings. They’re perfect for grabbing a half dozen for the weekend (or to freeze for later), and they keep really well. They offer a solid lunch menu too—my husband is loyal to the Hungryman, which is massive and actually keeps him full for hours. One thing I really appreciate is that they don’t skimp on the cream cheese with to-go orders, which feels rare these days. Overall, a reliable spot for a weekend treat or an easy brunch spread. The only reason it’s not a full five stars is that I haven’t experienced it in person yet—but based on the food alone, it’s definitely worth checking out.

Kim the Kangaroo 3 years ago

I had a French toast bagel with strawberry cream cheese, and it was good. They certainly didn't go light on the cream cheese, which was perfectly fine with me! They loaded it up! I also had a chicken salad sandwich on wheat toast and it was really good... nothing fancy, but yummy. I'm looking forward to going back again soon! It's a great stop for breakfast or lunch.